WHAT IS DELAYING AUTONOMOUS DRIVING AND WHAT REGIONS ARE AHEAD?
Regulation will finally allow Level 3 autonomous driving from this year.
In Europe, Japan, and China, approval of SAE Level 3 autonomous driving features, such as Audi’s AI Traffic Jam Pilot, is not currently allowed. The delay to key regulatory amendment has stopped Audi’s Lv.3 deployment strategy since 2018, but only until the UNECE-Automated Lane Keeping Systems regulation came in to force this year. Europe and Japan will benefit from the changes in regulation due to the combination of the technological capabilities in Level 3 of their domestic carmakers and the favorable political framework geared towards removing roadblocks and establishing their respective markets as key innovation hubs.
Germany and Japan are early adopters
Europe is the leading geography in terms of penetration of ADAS (Advanced Driver Assistance Systems) technology, thanks to innovation primarily from German carmakers. Lv.2-D availability in Europe reached 91 models in 2019 as Volume brands such as Renault, Citroen and Honda introduced Traffic Jam Assist features. Mercedes has already stated that its new S-Class equipped with the new DRIVE PILOT will switch on Level 3 by late ’21 on suitable highways in Germany. We expect Audi, and BMW to join Mercedes-Benz among the first to activate Level 3 via Over-the-Air-Updates in Europe.
Before the pandemic hit, Japan aimed to align its Autonomous Driving regulatory framework with Europe aiming to unlock Lv.3 for the 2020 Tokyo Olympics. In Jan’20, Japan even announced safety standards for Lv3. We expect that Level 3 demonstrations in Japan during the 2021 Tokyo Olympics will demonstrate its technological innovation led by Nissan who will offer its first Level 3 Pro-Pilot feature in the Skyline.
2. Insurance to take a hit – market education needed
Level 3 - Autonomous Driving presents a major challenge to traditional vehicle insurance due to its key implications for the determination of liability. In Level 3, the transfer of vehicle control from the driver to the Automated Driving System has implications for the determination of liability since the driver is still the ultimate back-up. This also creates insurance challenges for higher levels of automation. More specifically, since the Liability framework for Level 3 is still largely unconfirmed, insurance tools are not in place for this level of automation.
The above challenges the development of Level 2 and Level 3 features by manufacturers. However, carmakers, including Audi and Volvo have claimed that they will be accountable for potential failures when their ADS are active. The ALKS regulation mandates vehicles to be equipped with a Data Storage System for Automated Driving — the so-called “black box” — which will record when ALKS is activated. Car manufacturers must also introduce Driver Availability Recognition Systems, which monitor seatbelt use and monitor the driver’s capability to take back control of the vehicle, including through spotting eye blinking and closure.
Among automotive industry associations, the GEAR 2030 has expressed the views that “motor insurance and product liability directives are sufficient for upcoming systems, whereas harmonisation of national liability regimes is neither needed nor feasible for the upcoming systems”. We see the need for adequate education of drivers, from both carmakers as well as rating associations such as the NCAP to help them understand their legal requirements and avoid consumer confusion over driver responsibilities or even misuse resulting from “mode confusion”.
3. Cyber Security moves to the top of the agenda
Over the next decade, as transportation progresses from Connected and Partially-Automated to Highly and Fully-automated, Smart and Shared Mobility, the addition of new sensors and ECUs, new architecture, more Connected devices, and V2X will significantly enlarge the vehicle ‘’attack surface”. Identifying, mitigating, and responding to cyber threats will not only be paramount for physical road and vehicle safety but also a prerequisite for the transition towards self-driving cars. ALKS will also need to comply with cyber-security and software update requirements set out in two other new U.N. regulations. New regulations on automotive cyber security and software updates to establish clear performance and audit requirements for OEMs are coming into effect this year.
4. ADAS Suppliers poised for growth
ADAS suppliers are well-positioned to monetize the revenue growth coming from the proliferation of ADAS. They have significant expertise in the design, development, and delivery of components for ADAS and/or ADAS features, which gives them an edge over many OEMs. Leading ADAS suppliers are in a unique position to supply multiple OEMs with technology which provides them with a wide customer base but they also can sell their ADAS portfolio directly. Furthermore, leading Tier-1s have announced a continuing investment in human capital and expansion of production capacity, especially for radars and Lidar sensors. Leading ADAS suppliers, have a well-diversified revenue base and worldwide presence to capitalize on growth in different regions, i.e. currently in advanced car markets but later on in high potential, emerging car markets.
"Who is liable for a crash when L3 is in ‘’active mode’? Data recording would be useful to understand if the system failed or transferred control to the driver who failed to ‘’react’’ ."
"Carmakers, including Audi and Volvo have claimed that they will be accountable for potential failures when their ADS are active."
Fighting off new entrants: new expertise & collaborative business models needed
As mobility shifts from product to service, the world’s biggest automotive suppliers are striving to develop capabilities in AI & software. Bosch is committed to investing 300 million euros by 2021 in the development of the Bosch Center of Artificial Intelligence which already operates in India, the U.S., and Germany. But even though they invest heavily to support the autonomous driving and connectivity roadmaps of carmakers, tech giants entering the mobility space seem to be closer to bring new services to the market.
"As mobility shifts from product to service, most of the world’s biggest automotive suppliers are striving to develop capabilities in AI & software."
Auto2x, which stands for ‘’automotive-connected-to-everything’’, is a London-based automotive consultancy that offers business intelligence and consulting to the automotive, investment and technology sectors, on technologies that will enable the transition towards the future of the automotive industry:
- Intelligent & Autonomous Vehicles: ADAS & Automated Driving, Connected Cars (incl. OTA), Automotive Cyber Security, V2X
- Efficient & Smart mobility: Alternative powertrains (AFV) and new mobility business models.
Our report portfolio delivers instant access to expert insights on high-growth automotive segments with emphasis on leading performers, technology adoption, regulation and competitive assessment. Our services also include custom research and consulting to assist you secure a leadership position or help you gain competitive advantage.